- Chapter 1: Cakes and Cataclysms
- Chapter 2: The Guy Who Made Me Swear Off Men Forever
- Chapter 3: The Devil Himself
- Chapter 4: I Need A Very Strong Drink
- Chapter 5: Aftermath
- Chapter 6: The Devil Always Has An Excuse
- Chapter 7: Sugar Sweet Sin
- Chapter 8: In Which I Make Up A Boyfriend
- Chapter 9: Mama Pat Is Always Right
- Chapter 10: The Devil's Party
- Chapter 11: Things I Can't Forget
- Chapter 12: Encounter on the Beach
- Chapter 13: Facing the Demons
- Chapter 14: In Which I Almost Make A Very Bad Decision
- Chapter 15: Meeting the Boyfriend
- Chapter 16: Damsel in Distress
- Chapter 17: In Which The Devil Performs A Rescue
- Chapter 18: I Didn't Imagine It
- Chapter 19: A Match
- Chapter 20: All The Things That Aren't The Same
- Chapter 21: Our First Time
- Chapter 22: It Will Never Be Over
- Chapter 23: A Blind Date
- Chapter 24: From Bad Date To Worst Date
- Chapter 25: Date, Interrupted
- Chapter 26: "Tell Me You Love Him"
- Chapter 27: A Tasting
- Chapter 28: Heating Up In The Kitchen
- Chapter 29: His First Taste
- Chapter 30: Just One More Taste
- Chapter 31: In Which I Make A Very Bad Decision (Again)
- Chapter 32: I Hate Him
- Chapter 33: This Was A Terrible Idea
- Chapter 34: The Heartbreak
- Chapter 35: The Interview
- Chapter 36: No Going Back
- Chapter 37: More Confessions
- Chapter 38: Dante's Game
- Chapter 39: Let's Do This
- Chapter 40: The Secret's Out
- Chapter 41: A Reality Check
- Chapter 42: Everything Changes
- Chapter 43: Things Get Seriously Insane
- Chapter 44: What Those Years Did To Me
- Chapter 45: Our Second First Date
- Chapter 46: Dante Finds Out
- Chapter 47: All The Truth I Need
- Chapter 48: Finding the Script
- Chapter 49: My Heart Breaks Again
- Chapter 50: Running Away
- Chapter 51: Oh. My. God.
- Chapter 52: This Can't Be Happening
- Chapter 53: And I Thought We Were Complicated
- Chapter 54: The Fontaines
- Chapter 55: Is This Our Happily Ever After?