Read with BonusRead with Bonus

FIVE

“Look, nobody’s saying you can’t date him,” Sam said quietly. “He’s our friend, not our boyfriend. And it wouldn’t be fair for us to keep him from going out and--”

“Ah-hmm.” Zofi had noticed my approach, looked up at me, and cleared her throat rather obviously. Sam’s voice abruptly cut off and she and Holly both turned around to follow Zofi’s gaze.

“Didn’t mean to interrupt,” I said apologetically and jerked a thumb back toward the grill. “I was just coming to let you know the food’s ready.”

Sam gave me a weak smile and mumbled, “Uh, thanks.” She looked more worried about whatever I’d overheard than interested in the food. Holly remained silent but looked at me curiously. It was more than a little weird to see two such extroverted chatterboxes be so taciturn.

I gave them a weak smile of my own and beat a hasty retreat. Alice had been hanging out with me, chatting while I’d been cooking. I’d already told Belle, Mari, and Naimh, and the three of them were by the grill filling their plates.

Sam, Zofi, and Holly didn’t get up from their spot by the loungers for another five minutes. By then, the rest of us were assembled around the outdoor dining table beneath the covered patio. Conversation was light and there wasn’t much teasing going on, with everyone busy eating. The table was meant for six, so fitting seven people wasn’t a big deal, but squeezing in eight chairs made things just a little bit crowded.

I was at the head of the table, as always, with Belle on my left and Mari next to her. Alice was usually on my right with Naimh and Zofi along that side, and then Sam at the other end of the table. Sam and Zofi brought their plates to their usual spots, but to my surprise, Holly set her plate down between me and Belle and asked Belle softly, “Mind if I squeeze in here?”

Belle arched an eyebrow before muttering, “Uh, not at all.” She got Mari to scoot her chair down a bit more towards Sam, and once I moved my own chair to the right a bit, Holly was able to get our last chair into the gap, a little bit around the corner.

Everyone smiled, we continued the group conversation, and we resumed our meals.

And then I felt a hand on my thigh.

I froze for a moment, but just a moment. I was used to all of the BTC girls teasing me from time to time after all, so it wasn’t the first time I’d felt a pretty girl’s hand on my leg. Even around this very table, both Belle and Alice would occasionally let their fingers trail across my thighs. I snuck a glance to my left, but Holly acted like nothing was going on. Revealingly, the normally right-handed girl was poking at her sliced chicken pieces with a fork in her left hand, but she otherwise kept up her typically effervescent chit-chat with the girls. I’ve already said she was an excellent conversationalist who could light up a room.

Nothing else happened during dinner, and Holly’s hand didn’t wander toward my crotch or anything like that. After dinner, the air temperature started dropping rapidly and we all moved inside to the family room. We had a very new flat screen Plasma TV, and the girls put in a DVD of some stupid rom-com. My family room furniture consisted of a 3-cushion couch, a 2-cushion loveseat, and a single-cushion armchair, all part of a matched set that included the coffee table. I always wound up in the middle of the 3-cushion couch that directly faced the TV, so that at least two girls could cuddle up alongside me. Tonight that turned out to be Naimh on my right and Holly on my left. Neither of them came as a big surprise.

What WAS a bit of a surprise was that Sam and Belle ended up together on the loveseat. While the two of them had become pretty good friends, they weren’t the closest pair in the club. Popular blonde Sam and model-pretty Zofi were besties. My baby Belle and cuddly Mari were besties. Gamer girl Alice was my best friend, although I wouldn’t term us “besties”.

Newcomer Naimh was the wildcard, although Alice had been quite welcoming to her and the two of them hung out pretty often. If Alice was with me, Naimh would usually then go join Sam and Zofi. And of course, Belle and I were really close and spent a lot of time together outside of the club.

The point is: I felt like I could count on one hand the number of times Sam and Belle had been alone together. But even after the movie started, I could see them putting their heads together in conversation, ignoring whatever was happening on the screen.

Alice wound up sitting on Naimh’s right side, squishing the four of us onto the couch. It made for a snug fit, not that I minded having two beautiful girls’ bodies pressed up against mine. I wrapped an arm around each of them, resting comfortably across each shoulder. Alice even reached up to rub my right hand a few times before leaving it alone.

Holly, on the other hand, gently tugged my hand downward about twenty minutes into the movie, placed my palm directly over her left breast, and then added a little pressure so that my fingers molded around the curvature of her underboob.

It wasn’t the first time I’d held a girl’s breast outside her clothing. While I would never be so bold as to cop a feel uninvited, all of the BTC girls at one point had done something similar to what Holly just did, making clear my touch was acceptable. But this was certainly the first time I’d ever touched Hollyin such a way, and although most of the girls had simply thrown their clothes on over the tops of their bikinis before dinner, I quickly realized that Holly had neither her bikini top nor a bra on underneath her shirt. And as I felt her nipple hardening beneath my palm, I felt my penis start to harden as well.

Ten minutes later, Holly snuggled a little closer into the crook of my arm and asked, “Do you have any blankets here? It’s starting to get cold.”

“Uh, well...” I removed both arms from around Holly’s and Naimh’s shoulders and leaned forward.

“Don’t get up,” Belle said as she stood up from the loveseat to my left. “I know where they are.”

Holly was quick to pull my arm back around her shoulder, with Naimh following suit a few seconds later. She left my hand on her upper arm though, at least until Belle returned with three blankets. She tossed one to where Mari and Zofi didn’t quite fit together in the armchair, with Zofi opting to sit up on the armrest. She handed the second to us on the big couch, and draped the third over Sam and herself.

Belle had given us a fairly big blanket, long enough to cover the length of the couch, although Alice waved it off so that it only covered Naimh, Holly, and me. Holly pulled her end of the blanket so that it draped over her left shoulder, effectively obscuring her entire body. And once we were appropriately shielded from view, she pulled my hand down over her breast again...

... inside the shirt.

I couldn’t help but inhale as bare female flesh filled my hand. This WAS the first time I’d ever felt a girl’s naked boob before, and my heart started thumping in my chest. Naimh felt the sudden tension in my arm and shot me a glance, but I kept my eyes on the TV screen and fought to control my breathing. A moment later, though, she slid her hand up from my leg and over my crotch, feeling the massive bulge there.

It wasn’t the first time a girl had handled my package. If seeing the tent in my shorts was exciting, rubbing my dick through my shorts really gave them a thrill. The first time Alice sort of rolled my shaft around like a ball of Play-doh while we were alone in my bedroom, she got super-duper excited, exclaiming how happy she was to know she could have that effect on me. She’d made up her mind that every time she saw me hard it was because I’d been staring at Sam’s or Mari’s tits or something.

It was getting hard to control my breathing with Holly guiding my hand into massaging her left breast and Naimh stroking her palm back and forth along my shaft. I closed my eyes for a moment and concentrated on being in the moment, on enjoying the feelings for as long as they lasted, because everything always stopped in the end.

This was the game.

This was the tease.

The girls would manipulate me only as far as they were willing to go, always stopping short of actually doing something sexual.

But I was okay with that. I’d gotten used to that. Belle had worried I was suffering from constant rejection, but I’d been truthful when I said I was happy to accept whatever they’d let me have and not complain about not getting the rest. Did I want to lose my virginity and get laid someday? Sure. But being patient and trustworthy had gotten me this far, and I loved every girl in the BTC too much to risk upsetting them.

And hey, I now had a girl’s naked boob in my hand! Progress!

That’s when Holly stopped guiding my manipulation of her breast with her right hand, and instead moved it to fondle my package. Or at least, she tried. Her hand slid up my thigh and bumped into Naimh’s, causing both of them to startle in surprise. Naimh jerked her fingers back first as if caught red-handed. Holly leaned forward to look past my chest and over to the Irish redhead. Naimh gazed back, a sheepish expression on her face. But then Holly gave Naimh a little grin, rubbed my erection a few times, and pulled her hand away.

Holly then slid her hand inside my gym shorts.

I couldn’t help but inhale as bare male cock-flesh filled Holly’s hand. This WAS the first time I’d ever felt a girl’s skin directly on my naked dick before, and if my heart had been thumping in my chest earlier, it was POUNDING now. Naimh felt the sudden tension in my arm and shot me a glance, and this time I couldn’t help but turn to look back at her with an expression of wide-eyed terror. Not that I was scared or anything, but I was shocked beyond belief that this was happening. A moment later, Naimh slid her hand back up from my leg and over my crotch, feeling the massive bulge of Holly’s hand inside my shorts and the way it pumped back and forth in an obviously jacking motion. And when she did so, those emerald green eyes darted straight to mine.

Silently, Naimh mouthed, “Oh my gawd!”

My eyes just remained wide, but I didn’t otherwise respond. Moments later, Naimh flashed a naughty grin and lifted the blanket to cover her shoulder. She then reached up to grab my right hand and pulled it down inside her shirt, inside her bra as well, and I suddenly had BOTH hands full of bare-naked titflesh.

My hips surged involuntarily as if attempting to thrust inside some phantom pussy that wasn’t actually in my lap. Holly felt the jerk and giggled, speeding up her hand pumps while I closed my eyes and let my head loll backward. She probably had no idea that Naimh had my hand on her tit, and Naimh might very well have no idea that Holly had my hand on hers. No matter, Holly literally took things into her own hands, bringing up her left hand to turn my cheek so that I was facing her. I looked down into her twinkling hazel eyes, saw the little smile on her face, and watched the way her lips puckered up as she closed the gap between us.

Holly’s kiss was sweet, almost tender in stark contrast to the way my hand clamped down on her boob while she continued giving me a handjob. I parted my lips to let her tongue in, sparred with it a little, and then pressed back so that my tongue entered her mouth instead. We made out quietly, ignoring the outside world as if it had ceased to exist.

And then the outside world announced its presence. With a grunt, Sam abruptly stood up from the loveseat and not so quietly stomped out of the room. Holly and I broke our kiss and stared after her, as did everyone else. I pulled my hands out of both girls’ shirts and sat up straight. Holly yanked her hand out of my shorts, and as we all turned to look, the blanket dropped off the girls’ shoulders and down into our laps.

Zofi got up first, going after her best friend with a look of concern on her face. A moment later, Belle got up and followed as well. And then three seconds after that, Alice went after them too.

Finally, Holly gave me an apologetic look, as if all this were her fault, and she got up to join the others.

We didn’t finish the movie.

Previous Chapter
Next Chapter